What Is In Okonomiyaki Flour And Best Substitute

                by Joost Nusselder | Updated:  December 13, 2020

Every month new cooking tips in your email?

Japanese recipes, cooking tips and more with the first email our FREE mini-recipe guide "Japanese with ease"

YES, I WANT THAT!
I love creating free content full of tips for my readers, you. I don't accept paid sponsorships, my opinion is my own, but if you find my recommendations helpful and you end up buying something you like through one of my links, I could earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Picture this; you’re in the mood for some okonomiyaki, you gather all your favorite veggies, pick out the perfect cabbage.

You lay out all the ingredients, and you realize… you’re out of okonomiyaki flour!

This is a perfectly normal situation, and we understand your pain.

What is okonomiyaki flour and a good substitute

While Okonomiyaki translates literally to “whatever you like best,” so technically, you can add the available ingredients at your place and make your own version of the Okonomiyaki.

So, what is so special about okonomiyaki flour?

Today we’ll be discussing exactly that. Additionally, we’ve also mentioned the best alternatives to okonomiyaki flour that you can use to get just the same (or even better) results.

So, read on ahead to find out!

What is Okonomiyaki Flour?

Traditionally, okonomiyaki flour is made from unbleached wheat flour and soy flour. There’s the addition of leavening agents and seasoning that add a kick of flavor to the flour itself.

This flour is made to rise independently and form a thick texture without any additional ingredients like nagaimo.

Initially, the okonomiyaki recipe was made with a blend of mountain yam mashed up, and slowly, okonomiyaki flour replaced it as a more accessible choice for everyone.

Some people assume that using okonomiyaki flour is cheating on the original recipe.

However, the aura of this dish lies in its versatile nature; you can make it whatever you want it to be!

Flavors and variety of Okonomiyaki Flour

Okonomiyaki flour comes in a wide variety of flavors. Each flavor has its own leavening agent and seasoning.

Traditional Okonomiyaki used Japanese Mountain Yam and wheat flour to get a thick and glutinous mix.

To mimic that texture, the modern interpretation of the Okonomiyaki flour combines yam flour within the wheat flour alongside other seasonings like shrimps and scallops. Some common brands you can purchase include:

That being said, there is no “correct” method of making Okonomiyaki, so you can easily swap out ingredients with ones at your home.

So, if you’re short on okonomiyaki flour, that’s completely okay. You can easily switch up the flour with one of these alternatives!

Best Substitutes for Okonomiyaki Flour

You can add whatever you desire to this Japanese classic; however, some combinations just work out better than others.

Here are some of the alternative flour options that you can use in place of traditional okonomiyaki flour.

Gluten-free Okonomiyaki substitute

Coming across readymade gluten-free okonomiyaki flour is pretty rare, so here is a quick alternative you can quickly whip up. You will need rice flour and some sort of thickening agent.

For that, you can use nagaimo; however, if that isn’t easily accessible, eggs are an excellent thickening agent.

This way, you can quickly get the authentic fluffy and thick texture of Okonomiyaki you know and crave.

All-Purpose Flour as Okonomiyaki substitute

All-purpose flour is a lifesaver, and chances are that it’s in your home already. From baking cookies to making a white sauce, all-purpose flour has it all covered.

Therefore, it’s an excellent substitute for Okonomiyaki. This flour provides the authentic pancake texture while incorporating the ingredients well.

However, this flour alone will lack the sticky nature of Okonomiyaki we all love, so we suggest that you add some yam starch.

Potato starch and the addition of rice flour work just as fine for thickening agents.

You can also add some portion of baking powder to add the leavening agent to your batter. This will make sure that the flour batter rises evenly and the pancake obtains its beautiful round shape.

Takoyaki Flour in place of Okonomiyaki Flour

Okonomiyaki flour is unbleached wheat and soy flour filled with spices and herbs to add flavor to the base. It rises without any additional ingredients and gives you a thick fluffy texture.

Takoyaki flour is made with a pang of soy sauce taste, making the batter a savory treat. It will give your Okonomiyaki a slightly rich and saltier taste with the soy sauce’s sweet lingering tinge.

Add some water and egg, and you will have the signature sticky batter for these Japanese pancakes.

The reverse is also true so you can make delicious takoyaki with okonomiyaki flour.

Conclusion

So, what flour should I use?

The answer is, any flour works perfectly fine. The whole essence of Okonomiyaki lies in making do with whatever resources you have.

Whether you have okonomiyaki flour, plain flour, or even the original yam recipe down, the dish’s authenticity isn’t compromised.

We hope this guide helped guide you about Okonomiyaki flour and all alternatives you can use in place.

Just remember to have fun and add whatever your heart desires. Happy cooking!

Every month new cooking tips in your email?

Japanese recipes, cooking tips and more with the first email our FREE mini-recipe guide "Japanese with ease"

 

Also read: this is how you make okonomiyaki and monjayaki

Joost Nusselder, the founder of Bite My Bun is a content marketer, dad and loves trying out new food with Japanese food at the heart of his passion, and together with his team he's been creating in-depth blog articles since 2016 to help loyal readers with recipes and cooking tips.