Worcestershire Sauce vs BBQ Sauce | Consistency & Flavor Differences
When it comes to seasoning meat before, during, and after cooking, Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce are two popular options.
While they serve similar purposes and can both be used to marinate, the two sauces have different flavors.
Compared to Worcestershire, most barbecue sauces are sweeter and thicker.
The principal difference between Worcestershire and BBQ is the texture and flavor. Worcestershire sauce is thinner in consistency more savory than BBQ sauce which is thicker and sweeter.
In this guide, we will compare the flavors and uses of both of these popular sauces you probably already have in your pantry!
Check out our new cookbook
Bitemybun's family recipes with complete meal planner and recipe guide.
Try it out for free with Kindle Unlimited:
Read for freeIn this post we'll cover:
What’s the difference between Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce?
Compared to Worcestershire sauce, most types of BBQ sauce have thicker texture and sweeter taste. They usually contain more sugar but they have a similar oniony flavor.
Both sauces are umami but Worcestershire is a specific sauce whereas there are tons of varieties, brands, and recipes of BBQ sauce.
The main difference between Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce is that the former marinades and seasons the meat, while the latter is mainly used for final glazing of the cooked dish.
There are, of course, other notable differences to consider:
Ingredients & flavors
- Worcestershire sauce: savory, umami, salty
- BBQ sauce: sweet, tangy, umami, smoky
Worcestershire sauce is a savory condiment made from anchovies, garlic, tamarind, molasses and various spices.
It has a salty flavor with tangy and sweet undertones. This sauce is often used as marinade for beef steak, chicken and pork.
BBQ sauce is a combination of vinegar, tomato paste, sweeteners like brown sugar and molasses, spices and sometimes other ingredients such as liquid smoke.
Another important thing to note is that some BBQ sauce may actually contain Worcestershire sauce as one of the main ingredients.
It has a sweet, tangy and smoky flavor that can be adjusted to taste with the addition of various ingredients. This makes it a popular marinade for ribs, chicken and pork chops.
Sometimes BBQ sauce can have a rich, deep earthy and smoky flavor depending on the brand.
Ultimately, the choice between Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce is a matter of personal preference.
Both sauces can marinate and add great flavor to meats, so it’s up to you to decide which one you prefer.
Experiment with marinating your favorite cuts of meat with Worcestershire sauce or BBQ sauce to discover which combination you prefer more.
Texture & appearance
- Worcestershire sauce: thin liquid
- BBQ sauce: thick glaze
The texture of Worcestershire sauce is thin, liquid and runny. The sauce has a dark brown color, similar to soy sauce.
BBQ sauce has a thicker, almost sticky texture. Its color and appearance can vary depending on the ingredients used in it. It can be anything from light brown to deep maroon or red.
Some brands may offer smoked BBQ sauce, which is a maroon-colored sauce with smoky flavor.
It’s important to note that BBQ sauce usually has a certain sheen to it when applied, while Worcestershire sauce does not.
Uses
There are many ways to use Worcestershire and BBQ sauce.
Glaze or BBQ meat sauce
BBQ sauce is ideal for adding sweetness and smokiness to grilled meats after cooking.
You can add a splash of BBQ sauce during the marinating process and then brush on more of it at the end to give your meat a beautiful glaze.
Then, add more onto your plate or straight onto barbecued or roasted meat.
Same goes for Worcestershire sauce: you can drip some onto meat for extra umami flavor.
Marinades
When marinating meat, one of the key decisions to make is whether to use a marinade made of Worcestershire sauce or BBQ sauce.
Although both sauces offer similar umami flavors, they each provide unique characteristics that can bring out different flavor profiles in marinated meats.
Worcestershire sauce is generally more acidic than BBQ sauce, and is ideal for marinades that will be cooked quickly at high heat.
This is because the high acidity of Worcestershire helps to tenderize tough cuts of meat, making them more juicy and succulent when cooked.
The flavor profile of Worcestershire is also quite versatile – its umami taste blends easily with other ingredients, making it ideal for marinades.
It can be mixed with various herbs, spices, and other liquids to create marinades that can be used for grilling, marinating, and even baking.
On the other hand, BBQ sauce has a more robust flavor and is great for marinating meats that will be cooked low and slow.
The sweetness of BBQ sauce helps to caramelize the marinated meat, creating a tasty crust when cooked.
BBQ marinades are also great for marinating poultry and fish, as the sweet and smoky flavor pairs well with these meats.
Additionally, BBQ marinades are quick and easy to make, as you simply need to mix together a few ingredients like tomato paste, Worcestershire sauce, brown sugar and spices.
This makes them great for marinating large batches of meat in a short amount of time.
Also read: Where to buy AMAZING Yakiniku sauce OR make your own
Sauces & dipping & topping
Worcestershire and BBQ sauces can also be used for dipping sauce.
Worcestershire sauce is commonly used as part of more complex sauces, such as steak sauce or tartar sauce.
It can also be used in marinades, dressings and marinated vegetable dishes like coleslaw.
Some people also like to substitute soy sauce with Worcestershire for sushi.
BBQ sauce is a popular dipping sauce for fried foods. It can also be used to top burgers, hot dogs, sandwiches and wraps.
Worcestershire sauce can be used to make Asian sauces like okonomiyaki sauce. It’s also used to make sauce for Japanese curry.
Noodles & stir-fry
Worcestershire sauce is a common ingredient in noodles dishes, rice, and stir-fries. It is also used to give additional flavor for ramen.
BBQ sauce is great for adding flavor to noodles, marinades for meat and vegetables, as well as stir-fry. It can also be used to marinate tofu or tempeh.
However, it’s not the best sauce for noodles and rice dishes unless you use something like Japanese BBQ sauce.
This sauce tastes quite similar to teriyaki sauce or traditional tare sauce.
Nutrition
Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce offer different levels of nutrition.
Worcestershire sauce is low in calories and fat, but it does contain sodium which can be a concern for those who are watching their salt intake.
While Worcestershire sauce is richer in iron, potassium, copper, vitamin c, calcium, phosphorus, and vitamin B2, barbecue sauce is higher in vitamin B6.
Generally, BBQ sauce is the unhealthier option because it contains more sugar, fat, and calories than Worcestershire sauce.
It is also high in sodium, so it should be consumed in moderation.
What is Worcestershire barbecue sauce?
Some types of BBQ sauce contain Worcestershire sauce as an ingredient.
This type of BBQ sauce contains all the flavors you love from Worcestershire, blended with other ingredients like tomato paste, onion powder, garlic powder, brown sugar, and spices.
For example, you can make a tasty barbecue sauce and add 2 tablespoons of Worcestershire sauce to add that extra umami flavor. This goes especially well with smoky bbq recipes.
This Worcestershire barbecue sauce is great for marinating, grilling, and baking meats. It’s also a great dipping sauce for fried foods or to top burgers and hot dogs.
Can you substitute Worcestershire sauce with BBQ sauce?
Yes, Worcestershire sauce can be substituted with BBQ sauce in marinades or in other foods.
However, it is important to keep in mind that the flavor profile of the marinade will be different depending on the type of BBQ sauce used.
Barbecue sauce, a staple of most kitchen pantries, can be used in place of Worcestershire sauce.
It should be noted that while it tastes similar to Worcestershire and may be used in the same ways, it is sweeter and a lot thicker.
The thin, runny texture of Worcestershire sauce will be lost if it is substituted with BBQ sauce. Also, the color of Worcestershire sauce is dark brown while BBQ sauce is usually red, brown, or black.
Final thoughts
In conclusion, Worcestershire sauce and BBQ sauce both offer unique flavor profiles that can enhance marinated and grilled meats.
The difference is that Worcestershire sauce is thinner and has a more savory flavor, while BBQ sauce is thicker and sweeter.
When substituting one for the other, it is important to consider the flavor profile and the thickness of each sauce.
While Worcestershire sauce can be used for marinating meats, its thin consistency means that it is not as effective at coating larger pieces of meat as BBQ sauce.
Overall, both Worcestershire and BBQ sauces are good marinade, glaze and dipping options that can be used to give food an umami flavor.
Read next: 10 Best Sauces with Mirin For Salads, Sushi, BBQ and More
Check out our new cookbook
Bitemybun's family recipes with complete meal planner and recipe guide.
Try it out for free with Kindle Unlimited:
Read for free
Joost Nusselder, the founder of Bite My Bun is a content marketer, dad and loves trying out new food with Japanese food at the heart of his passion, and together with his team he's been creating in-depth blog articles since 2016 to help loyal readers with recipes and cooking tips.
